{
  "assertions": [
    "motion(idle)",
    "uses(webgl)"
  ],
  "attempts": 3,
  "attribution": "\u201cstrands of DNA double helix winding and unwinding, folding and unfold\u2026\u201d \u2014 sketchgen entry 1867, prompted by profcarroll, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M under the treatment rules file. https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/1867/ Licensed CC BY 4.0.",
  "brief": "The canvas displays a dynamic, three-dimensional representation of DNA, composed of colored spheres representing the base pairs (A, T, C, G). Initially, the spheres are arranged in a tightly winding double helix. The central focus is the visible, rhythmic interaction of the bases: pairs begin to separate, and clear, temporary structures simulating hydrogen bonds are shown explicitly forming and breaking between the complementary spheres. As the helix unwinds, these separation events occur at multiple points simultaneously, illustrating the molecular mechanism of strand unzipping. The entire molecular structure is in continuous, organic motion.",
  "completion_tokens": 7222,
  "created_utc": "2026-10-04T18:20:06Z",
  "entry_id": 1867,
  "executor": "qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M",
  "executor_prompt_version": "executor-v3",
  "gate": [
    {
      "assertions": {
        "motion(idle)": true,
        "uses(webgl)": true
      },
      "attempt": 1,
      "checks": {
        "audio_context_running": null,
        "console_clean": true,
        "frame_advancing": true,
        "frame_budget": true,
        "is_looping": true,
        "revised": false,
        "sound_lib_ok": null
      },
      "completion_tokens": 2586,
      "evidence": "Names this sketch shadows (checked before the gate ran):\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 69)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 87)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 139)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 150)\n\ngate exit 1: checks failed: revised\n\nFixed checks that failed:\n- revised = false\n    revised: sketch.js is the sketch it revises, unchanged: not one line of code differs from the 210 it was given; comments, blank lines and whitespace are not counted, and a revision changes at least 5\n    fix: this job revises a published sketch, and returning that sketch \u2014 as it was, or with a number or two moved \u2014 is the published sketch again, not a revision; make the change the `Revise:` line asks for in the code that draws and moves things, and keep the rest\n    the line to act on: Revise: the same complex, winding molecular structure made of colored spheres arranged into a double helix, and this time showing the explicit formation and breaking of temporary hydrogen bonds between the separating base pairs.\n\nRuntime state the gate read:\n- frame_advancing compares frameCount at frame 84 of the 120-frame idle window (86) with the end of it (122); at load it was 0\n",
      "exit": 1,
      "ghost": {
        "events": 40,
        "ms": 4000,
        "played": 40,
        "script": "wander",
        "source": "default"
      },
      "given": {
        "kind": "parent",
        "lines": 286,
        "sha256": "0364fadd7b6b2b4e694f87ef5585f6e277a0a19a2266d7bd516626e9bf634af0",
        "shown": true
      },
      "model": "qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M",
      "ms_per_frame": 20.9,
      "num_ctx": 16384,
      "preload_s": 0.049,
      "prompt_tokens": 5120,
      "resources_loaded": [],
      "rules_file": "treatment",
      "source": "attempt-1",
      "total_s": 12.532,
      "wall_s": 259.42
    },
    {
      "assertions": {
        "motion(idle)": true,
        "uses(webgl)": true
      },
      "attempt": 2,
      "checks": {
        "audio_context_running": null,
        "console_clean": true,
        "frame_advancing": true,
        "frame_budget": true,
        "is_looping": true,
        "revised": false,
        "sound_lib_ok": null
      },
      "completion_tokens": 2578,
      "evidence": "Names this sketch shadows (checked before the gate ran):\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 69)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 87)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 139)\npreflight: `sphere()` is called inside a loop inside `draw()`, so this sketch builds one lit mesh per item per frame; draw the items as one `beginShape(POINTS)` or build the mesh once in `setup()` with `buildGeometry()` (sketch.js line 150)\n\ngate exit 1: checks failed: revised\n\nFixed checks that failed:\n- revised = false\n    revised: sketch.js is the sketch it revises, unchanged: not one line of code differs from the 210 it was given; comments, blank lines and whitespace are not counted, and a revision changes at least 5\n    fix: this job revises a published sketch, and returning that sketch \u2014 as it was, or with a number or two moved \u2014 is the published sketch again, not a revision; make the change the `Revise:` line asks for in the code that draws and moves things, and keep the rest\n    the line to act on: Revise: the same complex, winding molecular structure made of colored spheres arranged into a double helix, and this time showing the explicit formation and breaking of temporary hydrogen bonds between the separating base pairs.\n\nRuntime state the gate read:\n- frame_advancing compares frameCount at frame 84 of the 120-frame idle window (86) with the end of it (122); at load it was 0\n",
      "exit": 1,
      "ghost": {
        "events": 40,
        "ms": 4000,
        "played": 40,
        "script": "wander",
        "source": "default"
      },
      "given": {
        "kind": "previous",
        "lines": 286,
        "sha256": "0364fadd7b6b2b4e694f87ef5585f6e277a0a19a2266d7bd516626e9bf634af0",
        "shown": true
      },
      "model": "qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M",
      "ms_per_frame": 20.7,
      "num_ctx": 16384,
      "preload_s": 0.047,
      "prompt_tokens": 5569,
      "resources_loaded": [],
      "rules_file": "treatment",
      "source": "attempt-2",
      "total_s": 12.522,
      "wall_s": 278.755
    },
    {
      "assertions": {
        "motion(idle)": true,
        "uses(webgl)": true
      },
      "attempt": 3,
      "checks": {
        "audio_context_running": null,
        "console_clean": true,
        "frame_advancing": true,
        "frame_budget": true,
        "is_looping": true,
        "revised": true,
        "sound_lib_ok": null
      },
      "completion_tokens": 2058,
      "evidence": null,
      "exit": 0,
      "ghost": {
        "events": 40,
        "ms": 4000,
        "played": 40,
        "script": "wander",
        "source": "default"
      },
      "given": {
        "kind": "previous",
        "lines": 286,
        "sha256": "0364fadd7b6b2b4e694f87ef5585f6e277a0a19a2266d7bd516626e9bf634af0",
        "shown": true
      },
      "model": "qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M",
      "ms_per_frame": 28.2,
      "num_ctx": 16384,
      "preload_s": 0.047,
      "prompt_tokens": 5569,
      "resources_loaded": [],
      "rules_file": "treatment",
      "source": "attempt-3",
      "total_s": 17.575,
      "wall_s": 165.099
    }
  ],
  "ghost": {
    "by": "default",
    "events": 40,
    "script": "wander"
  },
  "job_id": 1880,
  "last_error": "rejected by operator",
  "licence": "CC BY 4.0",
  "lineage": {
    "children": [],
    "critique": "the same complex, winding molecular structure made of colored spheres arranged into a double helix, and this time showing the explicit formation and breaking of temporary hydrogen bonds between the separating base pairs.",
    "critique_by": "gemma4:e4b",
    "generation": 5,
    "inherits_source": false,
    "parent_entry_id": 1821,
    "root_entry_id": 1450
  },
  "loads": [],
  "note": null,
  "off_node": [],
  "planner": "gemma4:e4b",
  "planner_prompt_version": "planner-v2",
  "process": null,
  "prompt": "strands of DNA double helix winding and unwinding, folding and unfolding, manufacturing proteins. use spheres instead of circles. Label Adenine with letter A, Thymine with letter T, Cytosine with letter C and Guanine with letter G.\n\nRevise: try again and focusing more on modeling the double helix structure\n\nRevise: make a longer strand in a double helix with accurate connection across the molecules\n\nRevise: the same molecular representation of the DNA double helix, and this time showing a segment unzipping to replicate its strands.\n\nRevise: the same dynamic molecular model of a double helix, and this time showing the temporary hydrogen bonds forming between complementary bases.\n\nRevise: add more detail\n\nRevise: the same molecular model of the DNA double helix, and this time showing the temporary bonds between complementary bases forming as explicit hydrogen-bonded structures.\n\nRevise: the same dynamically winding molecular structure, and this time explicitly showing the specific hydrogen bonds forming between the labeled base spheres.\n\nRevise: the same dynamic, three-dimensional model of the DNA double helix, and this time showing a specific segment unwinding completely to initiate strand separation.\n\nRevise: the same dynamic, three-dimensional molecular model of the DNA double helix, and this time labeling the corresponding base sphere with its letter (A, T, C, or G).\n\nRevise: the same molecular model of the DNA double helix, and this time showing the separated single strands floating away from the main coil in separate trajectories.\n\nRevise: the same detailed, three-dimensional molecular representation of the DNA double helix, and this time the separated single strands begin to fold upon themselves.\n\nRevise: the same complex, winding molecular structure made of colored spheres arranged into a double helix, and this time showing the explicit formation and breaking of temporary hydrogen bonds between the separating base pairs.",
  "prompt_tokens": 16258,
  "publish_commit": "4328a1a663eb7874f657044f529991506ff40275",
  "published_utc": "2026-10-05T03:54:12Z",
  "rules_file": "treatment",
  "seed": 1,
  "shape": "VM.Standard.A1.Flex 16/96",
  "source": {
    "attempts": [
      "attempt-1",
      "attempt-2",
      "attempt-3"
    ],
    "entry": "https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/1867/",
    "index_html": "sketch/index.html",
    "repository": "https://github.com/profcarroll/sketchgen-gallery/tree/main/e/1867",
    "sketch_js": "sketch/sketch.js"
  },
  "state": "rejected",
  "statement": "This sketch visualizes a dynamic DNA double helix structure composed of colored spheres representing base pairs (A, T, C, G). The molecular structure exhibits organic, rhythmic motion as the helix winds and unwinds. At its center, the visualization shows the explicit formation and breaking of temporary hydrogen bonds between complementary base pairs as they separate. The bases move in a wave-like pattern along the helical structure while hydrogen bonds form and dissolve dynamically, illustrating the molecular mechanism of DNA strand separation. The entire scene rotates slowly to provide a complete view of this complex, living molecular dance.",
  "submitted_by": "profcarroll",
  "wall_s": 703.274
}