a lone tree on a hill. we watch its leaves turn from green to red to orange to brown and then fall to the ground one by one. Then snow falls covering the ground and coating the bare tree. It melts and soon buds form on the tree. Flowers soon appear, and eventually the leaves are green again. The cycle repeats.
Revise: the same seasonal cycle on a gentle hill, and this time show the tree shedding its green leaves and transitioning through red and orange colors. gemma4 · generation 2 · 1 earlier revision in the lineage below
Rejected by the operator: rejected by operator
You scanned this from a projection. Judge it against another · Like it · Ask for a revision · Swipe on from here.
— views · — likes
Brief
The canvas depicts a gentle hillside with a solitary tree whose seasonal cycle unfolds continuously. The tree’s leaves undergo gradual color shifts, moving from vibrant green through rich reds and oranges, before eventually scattering to the ground. The setting then transitions as snow falls, blanketing the ground and coating the bare branches, only for the snow to melt. Following the melt, buds appear, blossoming into flowers, and eventually, the canopy regains its deep green foliage, repeating the cycle indefinitely. The colors shift organically across the shapes of the hill and the tree.
Artist's statement · qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M, unedited
This sketch depicts an endless seasonal cycle on a gentle hillside. A solitary tree undergoes natural transitions: from vibrant green spring foliage through rich autumn colors to bare branches, then blanketed in snow, melting to reveal buds, blossoming into flowers, and finally returning to lush green. The scene unfolds organically without user interaction, showing the passage of time through continuous color shifts and transformations. The hillside landscape responds subtly with gentle undulations, while the tree's leaves change hue and form throughout each phase of the cycle. Snow falls gently across the ground and melts away gradually, revealing new growth beneath. The viewer witnesses a complete ecological loop that repeats indefinitely, capturing the essence of nature's rhythmic progression through the year.
The executor's own account of what it built, kept verbatim. A claim about the work, not a finding about it.
Judgment
Humans
0.47 over 1 pair
closer to its brief: 0.47 over 1 pair
Bradley–Terry over this population's pairs alone. 1.00 is the virtual reference every entry is tied against once, so few pairs pull a score toward it: read the ordering before the margin. Views and likes are engagement, not judgment, and are not in this number.
Agents
no pairs yet
A Bradley–Terry score needs pairs; none has been judged.
Two populations, two scores, never one aggregate.
Source
| Repository | https://github.com/profcarroll/sketchgen-gallery/tree/main/e/513 |
|---|---|
| Raw sketch | sketch/sketch.js |
| Raw page | sketch/index.html |
| Attempts | 1 |
| Licence | CC BY 4.0 |
| Attribution | “a lone tree on a hill. we watch its leaves turn from green to red to…” — sketchgen entry 513, prompted by profcarroll, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M under the treatment rules file. https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/513/ Licensed CC BY 4.0. |
Lineage · generation 2 of 2 in the line from entry 193
a lone tree on a hill. we watch its leaves turn from green to red to orange to brown and then fall to the ground one by one. Then snow falls covering the ground and coating the bare tree. It melts and
Revise: redraw with the tree trunk connecting to the ground
Revise: the same seasonal cycle on a gentle hill, and this time show the tree shedding its green leaves and transitioning through red and orange colors.
No children yet.
No children yet.
Click a frame to run that sketch in place; one at a time. The whole line from entry 193.
Provenance
| Entry | 513 |
|---|---|
| Job | 514 |
| State | rejected |
| Prompt | a lone tree on a hill. we watch its leaves turn from green to red to orange to brown and then fall to the ground one by one. Then snow falls covering the ground and coating the bare tree. It melts and soon buds form on the tree. Flowers soon appear, and eventually the leaves are green again. The cycle repeats. Revise: redraw with the tree trunk connecting to the ground Revise: the same seasonal cycle on a gentle hill, and this time show the tree shedding its green leaves and transitioning through red and orange colors. |
| Brief | The canvas depicts a gentle hillside with a solitary tree whose seasonal cycle unfolds continuously. The tree’s leaves undergo gradual color shifts, moving from vibrant green through rich reds and oranges, before eventually scattering to the ground. The setting then transitions as snow falls, blanketing the ground and coating the bare branches, only for the snow to melt. Following the melt, buds appear, blossoming into flowers, and eventually, the canopy regains its deep green foliage, repeating the cycle indefinitely. The colors shift organically across the shapes of the hill and the tree. |
| Statement | This sketch depicts an endless seasonal cycle on a gentle hillside. A solitary tree undergoes natural transitions: from vibrant green spring foliage through rich autumn colors to bare branches, then blanketed in snow, melting to reveal buds, blossoming into flowers, and finally returning to lush green. The scene unfolds organically without user interaction, showing the passage of time through continuous color shifts and transformations. The hillside landscape responds subtly with gentle undulations, while the tree's leaves change hue and form throughout each phase of the cycle. Snow falls gently across the ground and melts away gradually, revealing new growth beneath. The viewer witnesses a complete ecological loop that repeats indefinitely, capturing the essence of nature's rhythmic progression through the year. |
| Submitted by | profcarroll |
| Planner | gemma4:e4b · prompt planner-v1 |
| Executor | qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M · prompt executor-v2 |
| Rules file | treatment |
| Assertions | motion(idle) |
| Gate | attempt 1: gate exit 0 — motion(idle) pass |
| Attempts | 1 |
| Prompt tokens | 2214 |
| Completion tokens | 1975 |
| Wall seconds | 170.549 |
| Node shape | VM.Standard.A1.Flex 16/94 |
| Seed | 1 |
| Lineage | parent 195 · children none · generation 2 · critique by gemma4:e4b |
| Source | repository · sketch.js · index.html · attempts attempt-1 |
| Created (UTC) | 2026-09-16T17:44:17Z |
| Published (UTC) | 2026-09-16T18:19:12Z |
| Publish commit | 8724eab7460f3d9476a2a25d3c351194f332751c |
| Licence | CC BY 4.0 |
| Attribution | “a lone tree on a hill. we watch its leaves turn from green to red to…” — sketchgen entry 513, prompted by profcarroll, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M under the treatment rules file. https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/513/ Licensed CC BY 4.0. |
| Last error | rejected by operator |
The same fields, machine-readable, in meta.json.