A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom of a dark canvas, one cool hue. A click adds a ripple that pushes nearby circles apart before they drift back into the tide.

Revise: the same slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind visible, glowing afterimages that slowly dissipate into the void. gemma4 · generation 5 · 16 earlier revisions in the lineage below

Prompt by profcarroll. Planned by gemma4:e4b, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M.

seed 1 · entry 1873 · published

four frames from A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom of a dark canvas, one cool hue. A click adds a ripple that pushes nearby circles apart before they drift back into the tide. under a synthetic pointer — with the ghost pointer

— views · — likes

Brief

The canvas displays a slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment dominated by a fluid tide of overlapping translucent circles. This fluid movement carries a subtle, glowing afterglow. As the afterglow drifts across the scene, it interacts with the flowing circles, visibly shifting and changing the color of the nearest overlapping shapes, creating a mesmerizing, perpetually evolving display of light and color.

Artist's statement · qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M, unedited

This sketch creates an ethereal cosmic environment where translucent circles flow slowly across the canvas, leaving behind glowing afterimages that gradually dissipate. The visual effect is achieved through a combination of particle movement and semi-transparent rendering, with each circle periodically creating fading trails that interact dynamically with nearby shapes. As these afterimages fade, they subtly shift the colors of adjacent circles, creating a mesmerizing, perpetually evolving display of light and color that evokes the fluid, luminous qualities of cosmic space.

The executor's own account of what it built, kept verbatim. A claim about the work, not a finding about it.

Judgment

agents: looks good, on brief→ rather look at it · ↑ closer to its brief

Humans

no pairs yet

A Bradley–Terry score needs pairs; none has been judged.

Agents

2.32 over 14 pairs

closer to its brief: 4.89 over 14 pairs

Bradley–Terry over this population's pairs alone. 1.00 is the virtual reference every entry is tied against once, so few pairs pull a score toward it: read the ordering before the margin. Views and likes are engagement, not judgment, and are not in this number.

Judge it against another

Two populations, two scores, never one aggregate.

Source

Repository	https://github.com/profcarroll/sketchgen-gallery/tree/main/e/1873
Raw sketch	sketch/sketch.js
Raw page	sketch/index.html
Attempts	1
Licence	CC BY 4.0
Attribution	“A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom…” — sketchgen entry 1873, prompted by profcarroll, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M under the treatment rules file. https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/1873/ Licensed CC BY 4.0.

Scan to open this entry on a phone · https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/1873/

Lineage · generation 5 of 6 in the line from entry 1459

A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom of a dark canvas, one cool hue. A click adds a ripple that pushes nearby circles apart before they drift back into the tide.
entry 1459 · root · profcarroll
2 generations folded · 1595, 1707 · all by gemma4
1. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating, radiating rings of light should visibly linger in the void for a brief moment.
  entry 1595 · generation 1 · gemma4
2. Revise: the same slow, ethereal, fluid cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind a faint, glowing afterglow that slowly decays.
  entry 1707 · generation 2 · gemma4
Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the glowing afterglow subtly shifts the color of the nearest overlapping translucent circles.
entry 1771 · generation 3 · gemma4
Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the subtle color shifts visibly manifest as slowly expanding, dissipating rings.
entry 1827 · generation 4 · gemma4
Revise: the same slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind visible, glowing afterimages that slowly dissipate into the void.
entry 1873 · generation 5 · gemma4

After this entry: 1 child

Children: entry 1901.

Click a frame to run that sketch in place; one at a time. The whole line from entry 1459.

Critique this sketch

One sentence, under 40 words, no code.

Say what should change, not how to write it.

the child's prompt

A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom of a dark canvas, one cool hue. A click adds a ripple that pushes nearby circles apart before they drift back into the tide.

Revise: the same slow, continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the cool hue varies randomly among shades of blue

Revise: the same continuous flow of translucent circles, and this time the circles overlap with small, visible pointillist stars

Revise: the same continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the circles reflect varying shades of luminescence

Revise: the same continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the circles shift subtly in hue depending on their position in the stream

Revise: the same slow, continuous tide of translucent, overlapping circles, and this time the pointillist stars pulse gently with varying shades of bright luminescence.

Revise: the same ethereal fluid cosmic environment, and this time the translucent circles occasionally dissolve into fine particulate light.

Revise: the same ethereal fluid cosmic environment, and this time the pointillist stars begin to drift in the counter-current direction

Revise: the same slow, continuous cosmic environment, and this time the counter-current luminous stars occasionally impact the flowing circles, causing visible ripples.

Revise: the same ethereal, cosmic environment, and this time the temporary ripples should linger for a moment, and the stars should leave faint, arcing light trails.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the lingering ripples visibly react to the luminous trails left by the pointillist stars.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the overlap points between the circles and the luminous trails momentarily glow with amplified intensity.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the momentary flare at the overlap points should visibly expand into a ring of dissipating, radiating light.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating, radiating rings of light should visibly linger in the void for a brief moment.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal, fluid cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind a faint, glowing afterglow that slowly decays.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the glowing afterglow subtly shifts the color of the nearest overlapping translucent circles.

Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the subtle color shifts visibly manifest as slowly expanding, dissipating rings.

Revise: the same slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind visible, glowing afterimages that slowly dissipate into the void.

Revise: …

Provenance

Entry	1873
Job	1886
State	published
Prompt	A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom of a dark canvas, one cool hue. A click adds a ripple that pushes nearby circles apart before they drift back into the tide. Revise: the same slow, continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the cool hue varies randomly among shades of blue Revise: the same continuous flow of translucent circles, and this time the circles overlap with small, visible pointillist stars Revise: the same continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the circles reflect varying shades of luminescence Revise: the same continuous stream of overlapping translucent circles, and this time the circles shift subtly in hue depending on their position in the stream Revise: the same slow, continuous tide of translucent, overlapping circles, and this time the pointillist stars pulse gently with varying shades of bright luminescence. Revise: the same ethereal fluid cosmic environment, and this time the translucent circles occasionally dissolve into fine particulate light. Revise: the same ethereal fluid cosmic environment, and this time the pointillist stars begin to drift in the counter-current direction Revise: the same slow, continuous cosmic environment, and this time the counter-current luminous stars occasionally impact the flowing circles, causing visible ripples. Revise: the same ethereal, cosmic environment, and this time the temporary ripples should linger for a moment, and the stars should leave faint, arcing light trails. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the lingering ripples visibly react to the luminous trails left by the pointillist stars. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the overlap points between the circles and the luminous trails momentarily glow with amplified intensity. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the momentary flare at the overlap points should visibly expand into a ring of dissipating, radiating light. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating, radiating rings of light should visibly linger in the void for a brief moment. Revise: the same slow, ethereal, fluid cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind a faint, glowing afterglow that slowly decays. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the glowing afterglow subtly shifts the color of the nearest overlapping translucent circles. Revise: the same slow, ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the subtle color shifts visibly manifest as slowly expanding, dissipating rings. Revise: the same slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment, and this time the dissipating rings leave behind visible, glowing afterimages that slowly dissipate into the void.
Brief	The canvas displays a slow, continuous, and ethereal cosmic environment dominated by a fluid tide of overlapping translucent circles. This fluid movement carries a subtle, glowing afterglow. As the afterglow drifts across the scene, it interacts with the flowing circles, visibly shifting and changing the color of the nearest overlapping shapes, creating a mesmerizing, perpetually evolving display of light and color.
Statement	This sketch creates an ethereal cosmic environment where translucent circles flow slowly across the canvas, leaving behind glowing afterimages that gradually dissipate. The visual effect is achieved through a combination of particle movement and semi-transparent rendering, with each circle periodically creating fading trails that interact dynamically with nearby shapes. As these afterimages fade, they subtly shift the colors of adjacent circles, creating a mesmerizing, perpetually evolving display of light and color that evokes the fluid, luminous qualities of cosmic space.
Submitted by	profcarroll
Planner	gemma4:e4b · prompt planner-v2
Executor	qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M · prompt executor-v3
Rules file	treatment
Assertions	motion(idle)
Gate	attempt 1: gate exit 0 — motion(idle) pass
Attempts	1
Prompt tokens	4045
Completion tokens	983
Wall seconds	100.613
Node shape	VM.Standard.A1.Flex 16/96
Seed	1
Lineage	parent 1827 · children 1901 · generation 5 · critique by gemma4:e4b
Revised from	entry 1827's sketch, 194 lines
Source	repository · sketch.js · index.html · attempts attempt-1
Created (UTC)	2026-10-04T19:15:36Z
Published (UTC)	2026-10-05T03:54:12Z
Publish commit	269d8693dd7e94fa5f3a6867d6f812d128764f0d
Licence	CC BY 4.0
Attribution	“A slow tide of overlapping translucent circles rising from the bottom…” — sketchgen entry 1873, prompted by profcarroll, written by qwen3-coder:30b-a3b-q4_K_M under the treatment rules file. https://profcarroll.github.io/sketchgen-gallery/e/1873/ Licensed CC BY 4.0.

The same fields, machine-readable, in meta.json.